( 42 )
J & I listened to this over a few weeks. We enjoyed them, though not all of it was a surprise since she saw the movie version last year with her Dad.
For me, had I read these individually they would have annoyed the hell out of me. These were not five books — it was one ong manuscript teased apart into five shorter books so that the length would appeal to the target audience’s age. Well, maybe not, but that was how they read.
Plotting was good, characters were nice, and Mark Hamill’s reading was pretty good. We had a little trouble distinguishing a few of the characters (they sounded the same) but there were a lot of characters in these books, too, so it’s understandable.
Not bad, all in all, but glad I didn’t buy it.
Story: 7/10
Reading: 6/10